In Chapter 7 of the Literacy for the 21st Century Book they give multiple different strategies of how to be sure your students understand the information they are reading. In my opinion, some of them are just busy work that give the teacher time in class to do some of their own work. However, the predicting, connecting and questioning strategies are three strategies I would implement in my own classroom. Predicting what is going to happen then reading to see what actually happens is a great strategy because you can see into their creative mind and see if they know how the story is progressing in regards to what should be next. Connecting the text to their life experiences, to the world or the other texts is also very important. This will allow the reader to look back on what they have read and remember it possibly because it is something that has happened to themselves in the past. This memory jogs their thoughts on what may have happened to the characters in their book by either it happening in a similar way or a completely different way. The questioning strategy is a good one if you implement a buddy system. In this you would have two students read a certain passage one night and the next day bring in questions about either the literary text or questions on inferencing things in the text. This way the students would be testing each others knowledge. They would also be able to use this as an assessment if the teacher gave them the questions they had to give each other, but they could talk about them together.
My placement uses the predicting strategy the most. My CT will read the back of the book and give them a general overview and possibly even read the first few paragraphs. She will then ask the students what they think will be happening in the book. They will continue reading and sometimes they have to write a follow up journal on how what they thought would happen and what actually happens is either similar or different. This also brings in the writing aspect of reading, considering they go hand in hand.
The evaluating strategy is the least effective since the readers are assuming responsibility for their own reading. At an elementary and middle school level, I don't think you can quite take what the students say completely truthfully. So, when they evaluate themselves they would be giving higher scores than what they should actually be getting. However, a good way of implementing this strategy would be if you had the students do their own eval. and you as the teacher did the same eval on them, except yours would have actual detailed questions. This way you would see the difference in their scores and your own and if they are being truthful or not.
Monday, March 2, 2009
Tuesday, February 17, 2009
Chpt 10
In Weinstein and Mignano, chapter 10, I focused on the idea of recitation versus group discussion. I found this topic to be interesting because it is something that I do not see that often in my class. The only time I really feel that I witness group discussion is during reading groups, when my CT is asking them questions about what they have just read, but that often seems to be more recitation style as it is talked about in the group. We as teachers need to be careful on how much emphasis we are putting on recitation talk versus group discussion. I Feel that some teachers may try or would like to do more group discussion, but because of the stress in the amount of material and lack of time, teachers end up falling back into recitation style rather then discussion/teaching. As mentioned in the book, we as teachers need to watch out for continuous recitation teacher, but also need to know how to conduct a whole group discussion so that is it results in successful learning for the students.
I also wanted to just briefly comment on the rubric website. I found this website to be very resourceful. It has so much to offer for a wide range of grades and subject areas. It is something that I will definitely use in my future teaching career.
I also wanted to just briefly comment on the rubric website. I found this website to be very resourceful. It has so much to offer for a wide range of grades and subject areas. It is something that I will definitely use in my future teaching career.
Monday, February 16, 2009
Recitation vs. Discussion
The Weinstein and Mignano article in Chapter 10 concerning managing recitations and discussions really got me thinking about how these apply to the kindergarten classroom for my field placement. Weinstein and Mignano break down the hazards of recitation exercises from the teacher, as they often overpower the students but do a good job of maintaining attention levels and checking for understanding. Discussions, they add, are able to achieve a slower pace and a more equal-role between student and teacher. However, discussions can sometimes exclude certain students whom choose not to participate as actively as others. Teachers often will back out of discussions so that the students can take the lead. This lack of leadership from the teacher can sometimes cause quieter students to sort of "check out" of the conversation.
In my field placement. I often see the teacher often lead recitation exercises during the lessons. Because of the students young ages, they often appear incapable of participating in a fluent discussion. The CT also feels that recitation can serve as a form of assessment. I feel this is best for Kindergartners and I am failing to figure out how to incorporate higher-level thinking skills into a discussion-based activity. I feel recitation at such a young age can lead to the greatest productivity and achievement levels for the students and perhaps discussion-based lessons should be slowly Incorporated more in the coming years.
In my field placement. I often see the teacher often lead recitation exercises during the lessons. Because of the students young ages, they often appear incapable of participating in a fluent discussion. The CT also feels that recitation can serve as a form of assessment. I feel this is best for Kindergartners and I am failing to figure out how to incorporate higher-level thinking skills into a discussion-based activity. I feel recitation at such a young age can lead to the greatest productivity and achievement levels for the students and perhaps discussion-based lessons should be slowly Incorporated more in the coming years.
Sunday, February 15, 2009
Instructional Intranet- Chicago Public Schools
The Chicago Public Schools website on Instructional Intranet tells its readers about the various types of rubrics and how to use them properly. One point I really like is that they include not only Science, Social Studies, Math and Language Arts in their fundamental learni9ng areas, but also fine arts and gym. Some teachers pull their students out of gym or art for various reasons of punishment, however with this website they view these two subjects as truly important for the students academic success.
The Math Rubric used in California is very interesting in that it allows the teachers to acknowledge that the students started the problem correctly and got up to a certain point doing the work right, however they missed something and incorrectly finished the problem. I think this is very important for students to see to feel as thought they do understand some of it or it was just a silly error and that they did receive some points. Often times the teacher just puts an 'X' over it and leaves it at that. This response leaves the student wondering where they went wrong, that could be the most important information for the students--what step they forgot or messed up--so they can go back and review the section they did not get correct. Maybe that will help them with other problems they did not do correctly.
I also like how they say rubrics "give you a means to clarify your vision of excellence and convey it to your students" because that is what us (as students) are always wondering for our first big projects... what does my professor/instructor expect/want out of us?! If you give your students a rubric, they will always know exactly what is expected and are not able to give you excuses as to why something is graded as it is.
The Math Rubric used in California is very interesting in that it allows the teachers to acknowledge that the students started the problem correctly and got up to a certain point doing the work right, however they missed something and incorrectly finished the problem. I think this is very important for students to see to feel as thought they do understand some of it or it was just a silly error and that they did receive some points. Often times the teacher just puts an 'X' over it and leaves it at that. This response leaves the student wondering where they went wrong, that could be the most important information for the students--what step they forgot or messed up--so they can go back and review the section they did not get correct. Maybe that will help them with other problems they did not do correctly.
I also like how they say rubrics "give you a means to clarify your vision of excellence and convey it to your students" because that is what us (as students) are always wondering for our first big projects... what does my professor/instructor expect/want out of us?! If you give your students a rubric, they will always know exactly what is expected and are not able to give you excuses as to why something is graded as it is.
Monday, February 9, 2009
Langer -- Understanding Literature
I took some valuable information from this article concerning the ways in which literature is disscussed and understood in classrooms, as well as it's importance in regards to critical thinking skills.
Relating to my kindergarten classroom, I see literacy being applied to many aspects of the daily cirriculum. Every day the students spend time reading books on their own and every day the teacher spends time reading from a chapter book to the students. During this teacher-lead read of the chapter book, the students are asked questions before, during, and after the text to check for understanding. In relation to Langer's "Possibilities for Instruction" (815), the students are asked to develop interpretations as well as reflect on personal experiences while applying the reading that they just heard.
I like the methods that my CT has used for her students when checking for literacy understanding. Even though much of it is both prediction and reflection based, I find it to be limiting about how you can go about dissecting the reading with kindergarten aged students. The students do not understand a lot of the meaning of the text without applying it to either something else they know or through the expression of their own personal ideas. The CT allows all students who raise a hand to express their opinion of the text and I feel it allows other students to get more ideas about the meaning of the literature.
Relating to my kindergarten classroom, I see literacy being applied to many aspects of the daily cirriculum. Every day the students spend time reading books on their own and every day the teacher spends time reading from a chapter book to the students. During this teacher-lead read of the chapter book, the students are asked questions before, during, and after the text to check for understanding. In relation to Langer's "Possibilities for Instruction" (815), the students are asked to develop interpretations as well as reflect on personal experiences while applying the reading that they just heard.
I like the methods that my CT has used for her students when checking for literacy understanding. Even though much of it is both prediction and reflection based, I find it to be limiting about how you can go about dissecting the reading with kindergarten aged students. The students do not understand a lot of the meaning of the text without applying it to either something else they know or through the expression of their own personal ideas. The CT allows all students who raise a hand to express their opinion of the text and I feel it allows other students to get more ideas about the meaning of the literature.
Sunday, February 8, 2009
Response-Centered Talk, McGee
This article focuses on the importance of response centered talks, what we as interns usually see as small reading groups in the classroom. It has been noted that there are two different types of discussion or talk that goes on between the teacher and the students, recitation and response-centered talks. As described on page 69 of the McGee article, recitation is "when teachers expect children to demonstrate their mastery of material or procedures by reciting facts and information they they have been taught". For example, how to locate a city on a map or asking for a definition. This is basically regurgitating information they are expected to know. However, the article is not implying that recitation is bad, it can be used well for geography facts, and so forth; but the use of recitation talk for literature is not recommended. As described in the article, (page 69, McGee) the purpose of response-centered talk "is the discovery or construction of new understandings about literature. Overall this article explains that through this type of talk students students can develop problem solving, reasoning, and interpreting skills.
I really liked this article because I strongly agree with what it is saying. Students would be restricted in learning one type of skill, reading a story and summarizing it to a teacher if all teachers did was recitation talk. My CT does an excellent job with response-centered talks in her reading groups each day. Before a new story is introduced, she takes a "picture walk" and has the students predict what will happen. She asks many questions throughout the story to get the kids thinking about different ways the story could unfold in the end. This way the students are doing more then just listening to the story, and summarizing. Definitely a type of teaching that I will strongly enforce in my future teachings. Like the articles explains, it is a could way for students to learn and explore a variety of skills.
I really liked this article because I strongly agree with what it is saying. Students would be restricted in learning one type of skill, reading a story and summarizing it to a teacher if all teachers did was recitation talk. My CT does an excellent job with response-centered talks in her reading groups each day. Before a new story is introduced, she takes a "picture walk" and has the students predict what will happen. She asks many questions throughout the story to get the kids thinking about different ways the story could unfold in the end. This way the students are doing more then just listening to the story, and summarizing. Definitely a type of teaching that I will strongly enforce in my future teachings. Like the articles explains, it is a could way for students to learn and explore a variety of skills.
Friday, February 6, 2009
Student Roles in classroom discussion
In Almasi's article, A New View of Discussion, she talks of the different roles students can play when having a class discussion and which would be more student orientated rather than teacher led. As we all know, whenever students can take control of a conversation with the class and have the teacher present, yet not disrupt they usually do. However, in my observations with my placement now and in the past I have not seen this happen to frequently. The teacher faciltates most of the discussions and the students listen and raise their hand when a question is asked. I would not know whether the students are understanding what I was saying/teaching or whether they were just staring off into space. When getting them involved in the discussion, whether it be as the inquisitor, respondent, facilitator or evaluator you will get more of them to participate because they usually do like to give their opinions and that is what most of these roles will have the students do.
This 'meaning construction process' (Almasi, p.53) also allows the teacher to assess what exactly the students are getting out of the activities/readings. It also allows them to see each of the students' strengths and weaknesses in order to put them into groups if you want to have small discussions or which students you want to prompt more often to get them more comfortable with speaking out in class.
Overall, I feel as though each class should have at least a few days a week be like this so you can get the students more involved. The more they talk and regurgitate what you are saying, the easier it is for them to remember it and recall it for future uses.
This 'meaning construction process' (Almasi, p.53) also allows the teacher to assess what exactly the students are getting out of the activities/readings. It also allows them to see each of the students' strengths and weaknesses in order to put them into groups if you want to have small discussions or which students you want to prompt more often to get them more comfortable with speaking out in class.
Overall, I feel as though each class should have at least a few days a week be like this so you can get the students more involved. The more they talk and regurgitate what you are saying, the easier it is for them to remember it and recall it for future uses.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)